[UW Augcomm Home]

[AAC Glossary]

[AAC Resources]

[AAC References]

[Contact Info]

[Disclaimer]

 

Missing something?

This site has been completely revised, but the old modules are still available. Follow these links to the old modules:
Old vocabulary module,
Old features module
Old funding module

 

Home > AAC Features > Selection Set > Message Retrieval Strategies

3. Message Retrieval Strategies

Only the smallest devices show all the available vocabulary at once. Devices with a larger capacity can only show some vocabulary and require the user to "retrieve" words that are not readily visible at first. An individual who is not able to use a retrieval method, or does not use it proficiently, will be unable to use that additional vocabulary during communication.

There are three different ways that users can "retrieve" vocabulary in AAC devices:

A. Levels and overlays
B.
Dynamic displays
C.
Encoding

And some devices use a Combination of Methods

A. Levels and Overlays

Questions to Vendors: about levels & overlays

  1. How many levels can this device accommodate at once?
  2. How does the user move from one level to another?

 

Levels and overlays are most often used with communication boards and books and low-tech voice output devices. Some devices can store only one level of vocabulary, represented on a single overlay with symbols.

 

photo of Ultimates 50110 (tm)                              
The Ultimates 50110™                                       
Access First, Inc.


(click picture to enlarge)
Parakeet 15
Zygo Industries, Inc.

Clinical note:

You can see that a device with a potentially large vocabulary might be functionally limited if the user cannot change overlays or levels independently.

 

Some devices store more vocabulary, but someone has to change the paper overlay to view the new symbol set AND change the "level" in the device, typically by pressing a sequence of buttons.

      

(click picture to enlarge)
Holly.com
Communication Devices, Inc.


TechSpeak 32
AMDi, Inc.

B. Dynamic Displays

Dynamic display systems are similar to devices with levels and overlays, but the levels and displays change automatically with the touch of a button. When the user touches a certain symbol, the display changes to show the next level of choices. For example, if the user selected the food symbol, he might get a choice of drinks, meals, and snacks.


DynaMyte
DynaVox Systems, Inc.

phot o Speaking Dynamically Pro II (tm)  
(click image to enlarge)
Speaking Dynamically Pro II™
.
for a computer-based system
Mayer-Johnson, Inc.


(click image to enlarge)
Springboard
Prentke Romich, Inc.

According to Blackstone (1994), dynamic displays can be challenging for AAC users because of demands on memory, visual attention, and decision-making skills. If you've ever gotten lost while browsing through multiple open windows on the Web, you may understand why.

Clinical note:

What is the difference in navigating through 10 screens of 35 items compared to 35 screens of 10 items each?

 

Some devices with dynamic displays have very small screens, such as the Hand Held Voice below. This means that the same amount of vocabulary would require far more screens for the individual to navigate through.


(click picture to enlarge)
Hand Held Voice
Mayer-Johnson, Inc.

Chat PC
Chat PC
TASH, Inc.

C. Encoding

Questions to Vendors: about encoding

  1. How many steps are required to retrieve each word or phrase?
  2. Are the codes preset by the manufacturer?
  3. How large is the preprogrammed vocabulary?
  4. Can the user make and store his own?
  5. How much vocabulary can be added?
  6. Can the user organize vocabulary? How?

 

Encoding is a technique in which the user retrieves a word, phrase or sentence by selecting a predetermined sequence of items. Codes can be based on numbers (e.g. 1-2-3 = I love you) or alphabet letters (e.g. ILY = I love you) or letters and numbers (e.g. I3 = I love you) or symbols (e.g. EYE + HEART = I love you).

There are many different ways to encode information. The best strategies organize information in a logical fashion with easy-to-remember codes for retrieval. If you've ever used keyboard shortcuts on your computer, you know it's much easier to remember ones like Control-S (to save a document) and Control-C (to copy something) than F8 (who knows what it does?). Symbols are reported to be even more memorable than numbers and letters. It has been reported that encoding places demands on the user's cognitive, perceptual, and learning abilities as the code sequences are learned. (Dowden & Cook, 2002)

  
(click image to enlarge)
Dactyl with "key-link" encoding
Zygo Industries, Inc.


(click image to enlarge)
Vanguard
Prentke Romich, Inc.

There's some evidence that encoding-based systems can become automatic to the user. He or she can learn to make the movements to produce the message without thinking consciously about the location of keys on the display. This phenomenon has been observed in both devices with static, unchanging displays (e.g., Minspeak symbol displays) as well as in devices with no displays (e.g., Morse code-based system). This is likely to speed up message composition.

D. Combination of Retrieval Methods

Prentke Romich's Pathfinder™ device combines two retrieval methods: dynamic displays and encoding.

The Pathfinder has numerous small keys and a bright display with symbols in it.
(click picture to enlarge)
Pathfinder
Prentke Romich, Inc.

Return to Clinical Considerations of Selection Set Features