 |
Fire and Burn Injury Interventions
Interventions to Prevent Contact Burns
Background
Toddlers, particularly children under
2 years of age are most at risk for contact burns. Contact burns are usually
due to hot stoves (electric, wood, coal burning), heaters and irons. The data
from the Harstad Injury Prevention Study33 indicate that 64.3% of hospitalized burn injuries
resulted from scalds, 31.4% were contact burns and 4.3% due to open flames.
Two-thirds of the patients were under 2 years of age and 66% were male. This
is the only study which has attempted to reduce this class of burns in a systematic
fashion (See section on multi-focal burn intervention programs for more information).
Review of contact burn interventions:
Author | Ytterstad, 1995 |
Study design and target population | Non-equivalent control group design.
Children under age 5.
Intervention community: Harstad,
Norway
Control community: Trondheim, Norway
|
Intervention | Burn prevention component of Harstad Injury Prevention
Study, a multi-faceted community campaign with active and passive interventions
including promoting sale of stove cooker guards. |
Outcomes | Hospital and ED treated injuries
Short term hospitalization costs
Contact burns due to:
electrical irons, electrical cooking
stove, electrical heating stoves, wood- or coal-burning heating stoves
|
Results | Contact and scald burns NOT separated.
52.9% decrease in injuries (52.4
to 24.7 per 10,000 person years), p<0.05.
Non-significant increase in injuries
in control city. RR=0.43, 0.23-0.82.
Reduction in hospitalization from
103.4 per 10,000 person years to 48.6 (rate ratio=0.47).
Scalds predominant injury; hot
coffee and hot water most common cause (2/3 of all injured under 2 years
old).
|
Study quality and conclusions | Multi-faceted community campaign based on known
risk factors a success.
Public participation and feedback of local
burn data considered important in achieving success.
Use of multi-disciplinary approaches,
active and passive interventions important.
Complete databases in intervention
and control communities; minimal effect of registration loss.
|
Summary of contact burn interventions
Product modification, that is, environmental interventions offer the most effective
methods for reducing both contact burns. Stove guards (protective rails) around
kitchen stoves and screens around heaters keep young children away from hazards.33
Burn injury rates are presented for contact and scald burns combined. Separate
data on contact burns is not available. A study by Elberg in 1987 also reported
reduction in scald and contact burn injuries as a result of a 17-year campaign
in Denmark.40
Data on types of burn injuries were not separated.
Recommendations on contact
burn interventions
Product modifications which prevent children from coming into contact with
hot stoves, irons and heaters would seem to be the most reasonable approach
to reducing these types of burns. Multi-disciplinary educational approaches
involving the media, lay organization and public authorities appeared to work
in the Harstad Project in Norway.33
It is not clear whether the same success could be achieved in larger and more
heterogeneous populations like the United States.
Recommendations for future
research
Engineering approaches should be employed to design safer products.
^ Back to Top
|  |