Science in the Lab Radish | Temperature | Brine Shrimp
Science at Home Photograms | Natural Fragrances
About Women and Science Books and Links

 

MODEL LESSON #2 Raphenus Sativus: Radish

To study the effects of the environment on development of plants, combining ideas of physics, chemistry and biology. To use the plant Raphenus sativus, the radish, as a test organism to assess water quality To design and carry out experiments to answer questions such as: how is plant development affected by the chemistry of the environment? How is it affected by light or by temperature?


Objective:

To compare seedling radishes maintained on clean paper in petri dishes moistened with one of these fluids: (1) water; (2) water at low pH; (3) sea water or 2% sodium chloride; the tests to be carried out at room temperature; and under conditions of strong light and in darkness.

Procedure:

Students should work in pairs. Each pair should have 3 petri dishes, in order to test: water only, in light; water only in darkness (petri dish covered with aluminum foil); and one other test fluid that the students can choose.

For each experimental test, fold a tissue to fit into the bottom of the petri dish. Add fluid to be tested to a depth of about 1/2 centimeter, and place a set number of seeds (e.g., 20) on the tissue. Close the petri dishes; for tests to be carried out in the dark, wrap dishes in aluminum foil. Place the dishes at room temperature or in the refrigerator.

After 24 hours, pour off excess fluid from each dish. Note whether the seeds have changed in any way. Make observations and measurements on each of the following 2 to 6 days, comparing the development of the radish seedlings under different conditions. Among ways to evaluate changes in radish seeds/seedlings:

  1. measure the lengths of plant parts (roots, shoots) extending from the seed coat (place, or even dry, the seedlings on millimeter paper);
  2. draw pictures of the seedlings;
  3. weigh seeds/seedlings, if equipment is available;
  4. match colors of seedling parts with a relative or chromatic color scale. This can be constructed in the color range dark green through yellow to white, using water colors, crayons, etc.; or cutting out patches of color from magazines; or in other ways that the students may devise.

Compare results from different tests; use the observations to describe conditions that favor or inhibit plant development, and draw conclusions.

Extensions:

Does temperature affect seed development? Petri dishes can be placed in the refrigerator (and compared with tests made in darkness at room temperature).

A variety of seeds can be used in place of, or to compare with radish (peas, beans, various other vegetable or flower seeds). Do all plants have the same requirements for development? (Consider plants in deserts, salt marshes, etc.). Effects of different wavelengths of light can be tested. For example, wrap petri dishes in blue or red cellophane instead of aluminum foil. Students can come up with other ideas for testing environmental variables.

Students can apply observations to real life problems, such as drought (if seedlings are allowed to dry out, can they be rescued by flooding with water?); acid rain; salination of soils resulting from continued irrigation; ways in which temperature range limits agricultural production.

The crucial role of energy in life can be introduced here: Where do the radishes get the energy needed for development? Can they go on living in these simple fluids? What conditions would make possible continued growth and survival of radishes? Do radish seedlings and Artemia hatchlings obtain energy in the same way?

Evaluation:

Evaluation should be based on activities and ideas presented by the students, such as:

  1. journals describing the tests and results.
  2. ideas about other conditions that might affect plant development.
  3. experimental designs to test ideas in (2).
  4. reports in which all the students compare their results.
  5. ideas about how experiments such as these might be of practical use, for example, in growing plants in gardens or farms.

Resources:

Seeds are available in garden or farm stores and from many biological suppliers, e.g.,

    Carolina Biological Supply Company, 2700 York Rd., Burlington, NC 27215 1-800-334-5551 Ward's, PO Box 92912, Rochester, NY 14692-9012, 1-800-962-2660

Background Information for the Teacher:

There have been many recent ideas on teaching plant biology, and an especially interesting example is the development of "fast plants", a special strain of Brassica rapa, that develop from seed to seed-bearing plant in about 35 days. The original work was begun by P. H. Williams and co-workers, and is described in:

    Williams, P. H., and C. B. Hill (1986) Rapid-cycling populations of Brassica. Science 232: 1385-1389. These plants, and a manual describing how to use them, can be obtained from Carolina Biological Supply Company.

Other References:

    Kordan, H. A. (1992) Seed viability and germination: a multipurpose experimental system. Journal of Biological Education 26: 247-251.

    Hershey, D. R. (1994) Solution culture hydroponics; history and inexpensive equipment. The American Biology Teacher 56: 111-118.

 


©Rural Girls in Science- Meeting the Challenge Through a Comprehensive Approach
funded by the National Science Foundation Project HRD-94500053
Dr. Angela B. Ginorio, Principal Investigator

Rural Girls in Science Program
rural@u.washington.edu
Imogen Cunningham Hall Box 351380
University of Washington
Seattle, WA 98195 (206) 543-7476 FAX (206) 685-4490