Elisabeth C. Miller Library

Gardening Answers Knowledgebase


Knowledgebase record #586


PAL Question

I recently built a 2-foot tall boulder retaining wall in my front yard. I have a small landscape bed along the top of the wall. I want to plant a small evergreen tree in the landscape bed to provide privacy from a busy intersection at the corner of my property. I'm pretty much settled on a Magnolia grandiflora 'Little Gem.' Do you think the roots of this tree will interfere with/knock-down my boulder wall, if the tree is installed in a location where the trunk of the tree is approximately 2 feet behind the wall?

Answer

Two feet from the edge does not sound like enough space to me. Although it grows relatively slowly, Magnolia grandiflora 'Little Gem' will reach at least 20 feet, and dislikes root disturbance. From the tree's point of view, the boulders might be a problem. Below is a link to general information about the tree, from Urban Forest Ecosystems Institute.

The following, from University of Florida Extension, describes the root system of this tree:

"The root system is wider spreading than most other trees, extending from the trunk a distance equal to about four times the canopy width. This makes it very difficult to save existing Magnolia trees on construction sites."

It is possible your tree might coexist peacefully with the retaining wall, but my recommendation would be to plant it as far away from the wall as you can, and leave the bed at the edge for perennials and small shrubs. Here is general information on the needs of tree roots, from Brooklyn Botanic Garden's Tree Care Primer by Christopher Roddick (2007):
"Out of view, and usually out of mind, roots make up almost a third of a tree's mass. Trees need a serious amount of underground real estate. Unfettered by subterranean obstacles, their root zones easily spread far beyond the tree's dripline, the perimeter of the tree's branches. If roots are curtailed by obstacles that inhibit their spread, the amount of water, nutrients, and oxygen to which they have access will be limited."

Keywords: Magnolia grandiflora, Tree roots
Date: 2008-02-02

Need an answer to your gardening question? Ask us directly!

Browse keywords or Search:

Keyword Search