China’s Trilemma

Here is a great article that tries to nail Chinese “off-shore” capital in the presence of Chinese capital controls:

Achieving the goal of autonomous monetary policy (in order to sustain growth) can be accomplished by either further currency depreciation, or tightening capital controls. The extent to which a combination of these policies will have to be pursued depends in part on how much capital outflow persist, with some observers holding apocalyptic views (e.g., “people are panicked”). On this count, McCauley and Shu provide a more nuanced view of the source of outflows.

Persistent private capital outflows from China since June 2014 have led to two different narratives. One tells a story of investors selling mainland assets en masse; the other of Chinese firms paying down their dollar debt. Our analysis favours the second view, but also points to what both narratives miss – the shrinkage of offshore renminbi deposits. grap2-A

Trumponomics and Sandersnomics: Trade Wars. Nuclear & Near-Nuclear Options

Substantial attention has been devoted to the disasterous effects of implementing a Trump and Sanders Trade agenda of imposing 45% tariffs on imports of goods from China. To gain some perspective, consider the implications for prices of goods imported from China if such a tariff were imposed (and a large country assumption used, so that only half of the tariff increase manifested in increased prices). Menzi Chinn has the scoop (be sure to read the cited WA PO and WSJ articles, too!):

 pimp_ch_trump