Love (Hate) Triangle

Today the Japanese Central Bank intervened (for the first time in 6 years in international currency markets). BBC has the story:

Japan moves to combat rising yen 

The Japanese central bank stepped in to sell yen and buy dollars, a day after the yen hit a 15-year high against the dollar.

It is the first time in six years that the Bank of Japan has intervened, and further action has not been ruled out. A strong yen makes Japanese exports more expensive, and reduces profits when earnings are repatriated.

In early trading on Wednesday, the dollar rose to 85 yen, after hitting 83.09 yen on Tuesday. Investors welcomed the intervention, sending Japan's Nikkei share index up by 2.9% at first, with the index eventually closing 2.34%higher at 9,516.56.

Economic harm

But in a brief news conference, Finance Minister Yoshihiko Noda said: "We have conducted an intervention in order to suppress excessive fluctuations in the currency market. "We will closely monitor currency developments, and take firm action including intervention… The yen's rapid appreciation "harms the stability of the economy and finances. We cannot tolerate it."

Japanese exporters praised the intervention. "From the standpoint of aiding the competitiveness of Japan's manufacturing industry, we applaud the move by the government and the Bank of Japan to correct the yen's strength," carmaker Honda said in a statement. Honda's shares closed up4%, while Sony, another big exporter, ended 4.2% higher…  A recent government survey suggested many companies were considering moving production overseas if the yen stayed high.

The record low for the dollar is 79.75 yen, reached in April 1995. Mr Noda did not reveal the size of the intervention, although the Dow Jones news agency reported that Japan's Ministry of Finance had initially sold between 200bn and 300bn yen ($2.4bn-$3.6bn).

But who is buying the Yen? The Japanese economy has been anemic since the early 1990s (the Japanese stock index has fallen by roughly 66% in the last 20 years).

 

Source 

Ok, so the Chinese government has been buying Japanese bonds, but their $20 billion purchases this year, cannot be the whole story.  Reuter's makes an attempt to explain the recent movements using interest parity (yield spreads) and sterilization – none of it convincing.  The one interesting piece is that the REER has actually not moved much less than the nominal exchange rate because of Japanese deflation.

 

 

Here is a final thought: when will we hear about Japanese "Mercantilism?" 

The Wall Street Journal spells out the Love (Hate) triangle all its juicy details:

China has been diversifying its $2.5 trillion reserves away from the dollar, causing some to worry that less Chinese buying of Treasurys would cause U.S. interest rates to and make it more difficult for the government to borrow.

But Japan’s dollar buying in currency markets Wednesday shows Chinese reserve diversification might actually lead to even more demand for Treasurys.

Here’s how. As China diversifies out of U.S. dollar-denominated assets such as Treasurys, it is buying debt denominated in the currencies of some of its biggest trading partners. Not wanting to lose competitiveness themselves, those trading partners in turn buy dollars to keep their currencies cheap.

As part of the diversification push, China has been a major buyer of yen, snapping up $27 billion in yen so far this year according to Japanese Ministry of Finance. Analysts say China’s buying has helped an already strong yen get stronger.

Now, Japan, feeling under pressure to weaken its currency, turned around and bought dollars, most likely in the form of Treasurys. It isn’t clear exactly how much dollar buying Japan will have to do to protect the yen from getting stronger, but it’s likely to more than offset China’s diversification into the yen. If the past is a guide, Japan spent $320 billion in its last intervention from 2003 to 2004. And this time the currency markets are 73% far larger, with $568 billion dollar-yen trading a day,  according to the Bank for International Settlements.

Japan is not alone in this phenomenon. China has also bought South Korea’s currency, the won. And South Korea routinely intervenes in currency markets, buying dollars to keep its currency from rising too quickly, again offsetting China’s move out of the dollar. 

Yuan On The Rise?

The picture from the WSJ below looks dramatic. That's when people say lies, damn lies and statistics

What looks like a massive appreciation is really only a 0.4% move against the dollar. 

[yuan0621]

From the WSJ Journal in Education:

SUMMARY: China's central bank allowed the yuan to appreciate to its highest level ever versus the dollar, possibly signaling a new era of exchange rate liberalization in global markets.

CLASSROOM APPLICATION: Student learn how central banks impact a country's currency in a fixed exchange rate regime. They also learn how market forces may affect the value of a country's currency. Finally, they discover how changes in a currency's value affects exports and economic growth.

QUESTIONS:

1. What are two factors that caused the value of the yuan to appreciate to 6.798 yuan per dollar on Monday? Check today's dollar/yuan exchange rate and comment on the size of the appreciation to date

2. What will the effect of the central bank letting the yuan appreciate versus the dollar be on China's exports? On American imports? Why? Use information in the article, and recall the Marshall Lerner condition and the J curve.

3. How does the People's Bank of China (China's central bank) intervene in foreign exchange markets to keep the yuan from fluctuating? 

4. Does the U.S. government want the yuan to appreciate versus the dollar? Why or why not? Do American consumers want the yuan to appreciate versus the dollar? 

Reviewed By: Marc Tomljanovich, Drew University

Rebalancing the Yuan

(from the WSJ Macro Weekly Review)

 
by: Kathy Chen and Jason Dean Feb 18, 2010
SUMMARY: The U.S. is expected to press China in the coming months over what officials see as an undervalued
yuan.
CLASSROOM APPLICATION: This article can be used for a discussion of the mechanics of exchange rate intervention
as well as the costs and benefits of maintaining a fixed or managed exchange rate.
QUESTIONS:
1. According to U.S. officials, China's yuan is undervalued. What does it mean for a currency to be undervalued?
2. Describe the mechanism by which the Chinese government maintains an undervalued currency.
3. What are the economic advantages to China of maintaining an undervalued currency? What are the
economic disadvantages?

Reserves Up, Dollar Down

Foreign currency reserves keep increasing, after taking a short breather during the crisis.

But the dollar share of global foreign currency reserves is declining, and at a rate that is faster than expected (via Menzie Chin and the IMF)

Reserves Are Revised Upward, the Dollar Share Declines by 

Perhaps the most startling thing about the new COFER (Currency Composition of Official Foreign Exchange Reserves) data on reserves released by the IMF is not the declining dollar share in total reserves, but rather the fact that reserves have risen….

The change is entirely due to the upward revision in unallocated reserves by emerging market and LDC central banks. This point is shown in Figure 1.

coferrev1.gif 
Figure 1: Total reserves, in millions of US dollars (black), emerging market central banks from December 30 (bold blue), from September 30 (teal); emerging market unallocated reserves from December 30 (bold red), from September 30 (purple). NBER defined recession dates shaded gray, assumes recession ends 09Q2. Source:COFER, September 30 and December 30, 2009, and NBER.

Total reserves were revised up $381 billion in 2009Q2, as were total emerging market/LDC reserves, and unallocated emerging market/LDC reserves. The revision in total reserves constituted a 5.5% change – quite substantial.

A straightforward interpretation of the data also reveals a continued — and exacerbated — decline in the identified US dollar share of total reserves.

coferrev2.gif 
Figure 2: US dollar share out of total reserves from September 30 (red), and from December 30 (blue). Source:COFER, September 30, and December 30, 2009, and NBER.
 
Question: How would you predict the fortunes of the dollar, it it likely to appreciate or depreciate, when global foreign currency reserves are up but the dollar share of the reserves is down?   

The Logistics of China’s FX Operations

From the Wall Street Journal in Education (edited) 

EU Voices Frustration With China's Currency Policy 

by James Areddy, Wall Street Journal, Nov 28, 2009

SUMMARY: European finance officials relayed to China's premier and central-bank governor frustration over Chinese currency's rigid exchange rate.

CLASSROOM APPLICATION: This article can be used to discuss the advantages and disadvantages of fixed versus flexible exchange rates and the mechanics of exchange rate manipulation

QUESTIONS: 
1. Why are countries pressuring China to "lift" its currency?

2. How would China "lift" its currency? What are the mechanics behind exchange rate manipulations?

Use the FX Market diagram for the Chinese Yuan that shows currency demand and supply, and indicate any changes in reserves.

3. Explain why the declining value of the dollar relative to the euro affects the exchange rate between the yuan and the euro.

4. How would a rise in the value of the yuan affect the economies of Europe, China and the United States?

Reviewed By: Edward Gamber, Lafayette College

Enjoy 

 

China Is Back On The Dollar

China's move towards a revaluation of the yuan were announced with much fanfare in 2005. Just as the People's Daily declared that reform towards a market based exchange rate had been successful, Jeff Frankel identifies that the Chinese exchange rate has returned to a full fledged dollar peg again (starting September 2008, see this link is to the technical paper, and this link is for the updated estimates). Did the Chinese Monetary Authority worry that the appreciation of the yuan might be  too strong as the global crisis spread and the move was to protects Chinese exports?