|
Transcritical Encounters in
Lacanian Psychoanalysis
By Bryan
Klausmeyer
Johns
Hopkins University
The
goal of this paper is to provide a
"transcendental critical"
interpretation of Lacanian psychoanalysis through an examination of the
historical circumstances surrounding the development of Lacan's ideas
and their underlying philosophical basis. Rather than operating as a
closed system, I argue that Lacanian thought functions on the basis of
"parallax" between irreconcilable positions (e.g., Kleinian vs.
Anna-Freudian psychoanalysis, structuralism vs. poststructuralism)
stemming from a central antinomy. To that end, Lacan ought to be
understood above all as a critic, in the same vein as Kant and Marx. [Article]
Fractured Humanity in a Broken
South
Modes
of Rhetoric in The
Sound and the Fury
By
Genevieve
Gebhart
University
of Washington, Seattle
To
best understand the ways in which the Compson siblings of William
Faulkner’s The Sound
and the Fury interact with each other and with their
changing surroundings, one must
view their actions and judgments through a rhetorical lens focused on
the Aristotelian
modes of pathos,
ethos,
and logos
in the
context of the forces of eros
and thanatos.
The setting
of the “broken” antebellum South provides a backdrop of tension behind
the story of the
equally broken, and breaking, Compson family. Each brother employs a
different rhetorical
mode — Benjy pathos, Jason logos, and Quentin ethos — to comprehend
their relationship
with their sister Caddy, the eros and thanatos of them all. Within the
workings of the
novel, Caddy herself is less a person than she is a strong symbol of
the erotic and thanatotic
forces present in human nature. She metamorphoses between representing
eros and
representing thanatos throughout each brother’s piece; eventually the
two forces become
interchangeable as her erotic vitality accelerates her family’s
thanatotic downward spiral.
Benjy’s plaintive displays of love, anger, pity, and fear; Jason’s
logotic hypocrisy and selfrighteous
sense of injury at his loss of the Old South; and finally Quentin’s
sense of self so
unrelenting that the pressure he feels from distinguishing right from
wrong leads him to
end his life—each demonstrate that the eros and thanatos Caddy
symbolizes govern every
decision her brothers make. Without the completeness of multiple modes
of thinking and
existence at their disposal, none of the brothers ever reach Faulkner’s
ironic suggestion of
“each in its ordered place.” Instead they remain perpetually trapped in
their fugue-like
mindsets, without the relief of another mode to render them whole and
set them free.
[Article]
Losing Faith
Rationalizing
Religion in Early Modern England
By Michael
F. Curry
University
of South Florida
In
the period between the end of the Thirty Years War and the
beginning of the
French Revolution, Western culture experienced a remarkable
transformation in
perceptions and understandings of religion among the educated classes.
One century after
the end of the bloodiest war in European history, the cultural
landscape allowed for
Julien Offray de La Mettrie to expound his extreme materialism and the
Baron d'Holbach
to flatly deny the existence of a deity without fear of execution for
heresy, and indeed
with the support of powerful figures. This shift in religious thought
is part of a larger
transformative process in the West during the post-Reformation and
Enlightenment eras
which supported the development of modern Western culture. The
effacement of
religious hegemony over Western societies allowed for rival sources of
values and truth,
such as nationalism, the natural sciences, or economics, to emerge. I
consider
this shift in religious thought by focusing on one period in its
development, namely, the
early English Enlightenment. Falling between early Enlightenment
thought produced in
the Dutch Republic and the later 'High' Enlightenment focusing largely
on French figures
and works, the English Enlightenment is important as a transitional
period. In choosing to
focus on this period, I examine the processes of development behind a
larger shift in religious thought occurring in early modern Western
Europe. I focus upon several authors, whose works exhibit trends in
thought that are shared both
with earlier works by figures like Spinoza and Balthazar Bekker and
later works
produced during the French Enlightenment. These trends show how
theories inherited
from earlier works were further developed during this period, becoming
increasingly
more radical and moving farther away from traditional religious
thought. I conclude
with a close examination of John Toland, in the interest of
showing how several common themes in radical religious thought combine
in a single,
cohesive philosophy. [Article] |
|